Our Guests All Cast Expert Fan Production team Al Brown Cast Antonio D. Charity Cast Brandon Price Cast Cathy Cullen Fan Chris Bauer Cast Chris Clanton Cast Chris Hewitt Fan Clarke Peters Cast Damond Gordon Production team Dave Pickering Fan Dr. Andrew Johnstone Fan Frankie Faison Cast Gabriela Jones Fan Gerard Ender Cast Hannah Dunleavy Fan Huey Morgan Fan Isiah Whitlock Jr Cast Iszi Lawrence Fan James Dyer Fan Jane Expert Jeffrey Pratt Gordon Cast Jen Offord Fan Jill Redding Cast Joe Kiely Fan John Doman Cast Jonathan Abrams Expert Lance Reddick Cast Luke Moore Fan Martin Austwick Fan Micaiah Jones Cast Paul Expert Professor David Nutt Expert Sam Pay Fan Scroobius Pip Fan Tray Chaney Cast UK Detective “Riggsy” Expert Wendell Pierce Cast